Skip to content

13 June 2007

ordeal.
it’s finals week. i proctored the exam for my class this afternoon. five short answer identification & explication questions and two essays in two hours. 25 students writing fast and furious.

i like writing and giving a final. finding passages to use for identification/explication questions is like a puzzle. they have to be representative and significant, but also a little obscure–not something we’ve talked about explicitly in class, but still something that my students can recognize and explicate. and timed essay prompts are difficult to write. they have to strike the perfect balance between generality and specificity, giving the students enough direction that they don’t flounder but enough rope that they can either explore fascinating ideas of their own (rather than try to regurgitate to me what they think i think) or hang themselves with their lack of preparation.

sometimes i feel bad for my students. as i walk around the room, i see the signs of stress on their faces. and, looking over their shoulders, i see which ones got caught in the snares of the identification passages–snares usually set by their own laziness or lack of attention to detail, but it forces me to admit to choosing passages with an eye for some slight possibilities for confusion. and i wince inside, because it seems like maybe i was unfair in the passages i chose.

but that always passes. because another part of me relishes their torture. two hours in which they have to pay the piper for all of those half-assed response papers and the stone-faced silence in class and the refusal to do the hard work of revision. the Machiavelli in me rubs my hands and grins gleefully at my students’ fear of a looming final, their strain under the burden of Too Much to Know.

in reality neither of those tendencies wins out in the end. i know that my exams are fair and that the students who have taken the time to do their work will be just fine. for them, the final is an opportunity to demonstrate their merit. because the thing about a final is that it’s really a trial by ordeal–a modern day version of proving virtue by combat. the ones who deserve to pass, do. the ones who don’t, don’t. and, just as with medieval trials by combat, there will be a few who are guilty as sin–who read half of each novel, if that; who only made a half-hearted attempt at writing anything; who don’t deserve to pass based on true merit at all–but who will try to find a way to pass anyway.

honestly, if they’re clever enough to find a way to pass without having done as much work as they should have, i’m okay with that. because now that my students’ final is out of the way, i get to look forward to my own ordeal. and trust me–while my success will be in part due to merit, it will also be in part due to my ability to b.s. my way through almost anything.

Advertisements
3 Comments leave one →
  1. 14 June 2007 7:32 pm

    You make me feel much better about my undergrad experience. I passed through all those trials by ordeal/combat. And it meant something. I really wasn’t too bad at the b.s. thing in the right context.

  2. 15 June 2007 8:23 pm

    Amy, teach me how to b.s. my way through almost anything! (actually, I think I’m pretty good, relatively speaking. But I’m not in your league.)

  3. 16 June 2007 7:24 am

    i’m going to think of being an excellent b.s.’er as a good thing…the funny thing is that this particular final produced both the highest grade and the lowest grade i’ve ever given on a final exam. and more D’s than i’ve ever given on a final. so two days after i wrote this i found myself wondering if it was actually fair. but one of my C students got a B and one of my B students got an A, and the grades do shake out into a bell shaped curve (with a slightly long tail), so it couldn’t have been that off balance, right?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: